PriorX is your trusted IP partner. For Inventors, Entrepreneurs, and Creators, we support those who are shaping the world.

Infringement Patent Search

Comprehensive analysis of existing patents & literature to assess novelty and patentability.

Infringement Patent Search

An Infringement Patent Search, also known as a Freedom-to-Operate (FTO) Search, is a comprehensive investigation conducted to determine whether a product, process, or service infringes upon existing patents. This search is crucial for businesses and inventors to ensure that their innovations do not violate the patent rights of others, thereby avoiding potential legal disputes and financial liabilities.
PATSNAP.COM

Importance of Infringement Patent Searches:

Risk Mitigation: Conducting an infringement search helps identify existing patents that could potentially impede the commercial launch or expansion of a product, enabling companies to navigate around these patents or seek necessary licenses.
NATLAWREVIEW.COM

service image

Strategic Planning: By understanding the patent landscape, businesses can make informed decisions about product development, market entry, and partnerships, ensuring that their innovations do not infringe on existing patents.
NOVOTECHIP.COM

Practical Applications:

Product Development: Before launching a new product, companies perform infringement searches to ensure that their product does not infringe on existing patents, thereby avoiding potential lawsuits.

Mergers and Acquisitions: During due diligence, infringement searches are conducted to assess the patent risks associated with the target company's products or technologies.

Recent Use Case:

In July 2024, First Solar, a leading U.S. solar company, initiated investigations into potential patent infringement by several rival manufacturers concerning Tunnel Oxide Passivated Contact (TOPCon) solar cell technology. This action underscores the importance of infringement searches in protecting intellectual property rights within competitive industries.
REUTERS.COM

Steps to Conduct an Infringement Patent Search:

  • Define the Scope: Clearly outline the product, process, or service to be evaluated for potential infringement.
  • Identify Relevant Patents: Search patent databases to find active patents related to the technology in question.
  • Analyze Patent Claims: Examine the claims of identified patents to determine if the product or process in question falls within the scope of these claims.
  • Assess Legal Status: Verify the legal status of the identified patents to ensure they are active and enforceable.
  • Document Findings: Compile a detailed report outlining potential infringement risks and recommendations for mitigation.

Future Scope:

With the rapid advancement of technologies such as artificial intelligence and biotechnology, the complexity of infringement searches is expected to increase. The integration of advanced search tools and artificial intelligence is anticipated to enhance the efficiency and accuracy of infringement searches, enabling businesses to navigate the evolving patent landscape more effectively.
FT.COM

Analytical Data:

Recent developments in patent search tools, such as the Intellectual Property Office's introduction of the One IPO Search platform, have modernized the process by allowing keyword searches across patent databases. This advancement facilitates easier identification of potential patent infringements, thereby supporting innovators in protecting their intellectual property rights.

service image

Types of Patent Infringement

  • 1. Direct Infringement: This occurs when an entity makes, uses, sells, or imports a patented invention without permission.
  • 2. Indirect Infringement: This includes:
  • A. Induced Infringement: Encouraging or aiding another party to infringe a patent.
  • B. Contributory Infringement: Supplying components or materials specifically for use in a patented invention, knowing they are intended for infringement.
  • 3. Willful Infringement: Deliberately infringing a patent with knowledge of its existence, often leading to enhanced damages in litigation.

Recent Notable Cases:

Apple vs. Masimo (October 2024): A federal jury found that early versions of Masimo's smartwatches infringed on Apple's design patents, awarding Apple $250 in damages.

Nintendo and The Pokémon Company vs. Pocketpair (November 2024): Nintendo filed a lawsuit against Pocketpair, alleging that their game "Palworld" infringed on multiple patents related to game mechanics.

LG Chem vs. Ningbo Ronbay New Energy Technology (October 2024): LG Chem sued the Chinese company for allegedly infringing on patents related to high-nickel cathode materials used in electric vehicle batteries.

Recent Patent Infringement Lawsuits

service image

reuters.com Apple wins $250 US jury verdict in patent case over Masimo smartwatches 108 days ago

service image

theverge.com Here are the patents Nintendo and The Pokémon Company are suing Palworld over 94 days ago

service image

reuters.com LG Chem files lawsuit against unit of China's Ronbay over battery tech

Market Size of Design Patents

Understanding the Client’s Requirements

Conduct detailed consultations to understand the product/process under review. Define the scope of the infringement search – jurisdictions, timeframes, and technology focus. Identify specific claims to analyze in target patents.

Identifying Key Patents & Competitor Analysis

Use advanced patent databases (USPTO, WIPO, EPO, Google Patents, and private databases) to identify relevant patents.

Conduct a competitor landscape analysis to pinpoint potential infringement risks. Utilize semantic search, AI-driven algorithms, and expert manual filtering to ensure comprehensive prior art discovery.

service image

Claim Chart (Evidence of Use) Preparation

Detailed claim mapping to compare patent claims vs. product/process functionalities. Develop visual claim charts showcasing claim elements mapped against the accused product/process. Identify strong vs. weak areas in infringement claims.

Legal & Technical Analysis

Analyze scope & validity of patents to determine claim enforceability.
Apply Doctrine of Equivalents & Literal Infringement tests.
Evaluate design-around strategies for mitigating infringement risks.
Consult with patent attorneys & technical experts for deeper legal insights.

Generating Infringement Search Report

Create a structured, professional report with:
Identified patents with potential infringement risks.
Detailed claim analysis & evidence of use charts.
Legal interpretations with potential defenses.

Strategic Recommendations & Action Plan

Provide legal risk assessment & possible litigation avoidance strategies.
Suggest Freedom to Operate (FTO) paths or licensing alternatives.
If necessary, assist in patent invalidation searches to challenge weak patents.
Continuous monitoring & updates for ongoing patent threats.

service image
service image
service image